It’s scary taking the road less travelled

Contrarians need to know when it’s safe to ignore ‘consensus’

“What is popular isn’t always the truth.  And the truth isn’t always popular.”
–Howard Cosell, U.S. sports journalist

Contrarians have a bad reputation. People think we’re ornery and reflexively pessimistic. I beg to differ. On the contrary (!), contrarians can also be rational opportunists who look for the silver linings and where the glass may be half full, not half empty. According to the Merriam-Webster dictionary, in investing, a contrarian is “an investor who buys shares of stock when most others are selling and who sells when others are buying.”

Warren Buffett, chair and CEO of legendary investment firm Berkshire Hathaway Inc., is a perfect example of a highly successful contrarian investor. He has been quoted many times on the topic: “Be fearful when others are greedy and greedy when others are fearful”; and “You pay a very high price in the stock market for a cheery consensus.” These musings are part of the everyday investor lexicon.

Let’s be honest: To be a contrarian requires having thick skin. Read biographies and you will find that most successful entrepreneurs had a contrarian bent, daring to see opportunities where others did not, and forging ahead persistently despite the many naysayers. When it comes to investing, the same applies. As Warren Buffett surmised, “A public opinion poll will not get you rich on Wall Street.” In the short term it is much easier to simply go along with the crowd – accepting market returns. In his earliest memo in 2006 to clients, Howard Marks, founder of Oaktree Capital Management, wrote: “This just in: You can’t take the same actions as everyone else and expect to outperform.” Appropriately, he titled a recent memo from this year: “I Beg to Differ!”

The cost of crowded trade

Beyond the wherewithal to stand apart from the crowd, you also need to have favourable odds relative to expectations. This requires analytical rigour. As investment strategist Michael Mauboussin noted, “A contrarian investor focuses not only on the general sentiment, but more importantly on how that sentiment can lead to disconnects between fundamentals and expectations.” By “fundamentals,” Mauboussin refers to the fundamentals of the publicly traded business; expectations are what are reflected in the asset price.

He gives the example of horse racing where the fundamentals are derived from the horse’s records and stats, and the expectations are reflected by the odds on the board. There are actually a few people who make a living by betting at the racetrack even after paying the full 17% vig, or amount required to place the bet, to the house. Betting on the favourite horse won’t get you far over the long run if everyone else is also doing the same. Rather, betting on the mispriced horse where other betters have occasionally misjudged the probabilities of winning is the name of the game. The best bet is never obvious. What matters is the odds. Everyone goes to the track and bets, and the odds change based on what’s bet. That’s also what happens in the stock market.

Assessing probabilities takes a disciplined mindset. Today, consumer sentiment is exceptionally gloomy. Being a contrarian on autopilot can be as hazardous to future returns as blindly following herd behavior. Tactical or rational contrarianism exploits expectation gaps during periods of market inefficiency, which tends to be higher when investor sentiment is extreme. It is harder to be rational when your mind is in an agitated state.

When the wisdom of crowds breaks down

Rational contrarianism does not come naturally to most people. Like other species, through millennia humans have learned to cling together for safety. Specifically, in the investing world, and for professional reasons, it’s often easier to hew to benchmarks than to diverge from them. It’s impossible to practice rational contrarianism without independence and a long-term orientation.

Here’s the thing: The crowd is usually, roughly, right; the key is to identify those situations and conditions when the crowd is likely to be wrong. One of my favourite books on the subject is Wisdom of Crowds by James Surowiecki where he describes five conditions when crowds are likely to be right. You probably should not make big bets against the crowd when those conditions hold, but there are times when the crowd’s “wisdom” breaks down. That’s when independent thinking has a greater chance to pay off. 

Being a contrarian requires a strong will and patience. The path of least resistance is to go with the flow but, as an investor, that strategy rarely generates above-average long-term returns.

The opportunity to engage in critical thinking comes from running an independently-owned business and taking a long-term view of capital growth. It’s fitting that The Pender Credo (see the table below), which delineates our key differentiators, includes the phrase: “We are occasionally contrarian.” It also states, “We are independent thinkers and patient opportunists focused on owning businesses, not trading stocks.” These are not simply words; they are values we embody through all market cycles.

As the end of this month marks Hallowe’en, I’ll sign off with a treat (not a trick) from Buffett: “A contrarian approach is just as foolish as a follow-the-crowd strategy. What’s required is thinking rather than polling.”

To learn more about Pender’s investment philosophy, read our memo “The Pender Edge.”

Felix Narhi, CFA, is Chief Investment Officer and Portfolio Manager at PenderFund Capital Management and Portfolio Manager of the Pender Global Focused Fund and the Pender Strategic Growth and Income Fund. This article first appeared in the Pender blog. Used with permission.

Notes and Disclaimer

Commissions, trailing commissions, management fees and expenses all may be associated with mutual fund investments. Please read the simplified prospectus before investing. The indicated rates of return are the historical annual compounded total returns including changes in net asset value and assume reinvestment of all distributions and are net of all management and administrative fees, but do not take into account sales, redemption or optional charges or income taxes payable by any security holder that would have reduced returns. Mutual funds are not guaranteed, their values change frequently and past performance may not be repeated. This communication is intended for information purposes only and does not constitute an offer to buy or sell our products or services nor is it intended as investment and/or financial advice on any subject matter and is provided for your information only. Every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of its contents. Certain of the statements made may contain forward-looking statements, which involve known and unknown risk, uncertainties and other factors which may cause the actual results, performance or achievements of the Company, or industry results, to be materially different from any future results, performance or achievements expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements.