Try Fund Library Premium
For Free with a 30 day trial!
First, what do we mean by rules-based investing? Rules-based, or quantitative (quant) investing is a data-driven process whereby trades are made based on quantitative factors or rules, effectively taken human emotional biases out of the equation. Why do we want to take emotional biases out? Because they are what prevents active investors from beating the market.
We are better than computers at a LOT of tasks, but unbiased decision-making is not one of them. That’s why according to S&P’s SPIVA research, a study of active fund managers versus their benchmarks, 93% of Canadian Equity funds underperformed the S&P/TSX Composite Index over the past 10 years, and 85% of large-cap funds in the U.S. underperformed the S&P 500. According to Fundata, the S&P 500 has significantly outperformed the U.S. Equity category average across all time periods. Results are similar for the Canadian Equity category.
There are many reasons we make bad investment decisions. Smart Asset has written about 10 cognitive biases that hurt your portfolio. Here is a summary:
1. Confirmation bias: Looking for information to confirm something you already believe.
2. Cognitive dissonance: Difficulty deciding against something you believe.
3. Loss aversion: Fear of loss outweighs value of gains.
4. Risk aversion: Preference for safer, more “predictable” outcomes.
5. Herd mentality: Following the crowd.
6. Anchoring: Too much emphasis on the first piece of information.
7. Endowment effect: Becoming attached to and overvaluing things you own.
8. Status quo bias: It’s easier to maintain current state than to make changes.
9. Recency bias: Events that have happened recently get higher priority than past events.
10. Representative bias: Assuming Company A will perform similarly to Company B because they are in the same industry.
Taking the human emotions out of investing and letting the data do the work can really pay off, especially during periods with a lot of uncertainty. Investors experience a lot of feelings that have little or nothing to do with investing or the markets. Feelings that could be driven by personal circumstances, political views, something you heard in the news, or something as simple as the weather. These feelings can lead to overly negative or positive thoughts towards your investments. You might look at your portfolio, see that it’s down this week, and think, “This is terrible, and things are only going to get worse.” But are they really that bad? Is that what the numbers say? Or is it just part of a normal drawdown in a healthy market?
Of course, the numbers can be wrong sometimes too, there is no such thing as a perfect system, but there are a lot more factors at play for humans, and a lot more noise in the decisions making, that can lead investors to make bad decisions.
When you have a rules-based process based on tens of thousands of data points going back 50 years, with hundreds of iterations and tested hundreds of factors, you have something that can cut out the noise and focus on the factors that actually make a difference to your returns.
At some point almost every investor thinks they can beat the market by picking stocks. I know I did in my early days, but even the most highly trained investors can make decisions that leave them trailing the markets.
Reid Baker, CERA, ASA, is the founder and CEO of ForAll Investment Research. He created the ForAll Core & More U.S. Equity Index, which is tracked by the ForAll Core & More U.S. Equity Index ETF (FORU).
Notes and Disclaimers
Content copyright © 2025 by ForAll Investment Research Inc. All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part by any means without prior written permission is prohibited. This article is used with permission on this website. All investing is subject to risk, including the possible loss of the money you invest. Be aware that fluctuations in the financial markets and other factors may cause declines in the value of your account. There is no guarantee that any particular asset allocation or mix of funds will meet your investment objectives or provide you with a given level of income. Diversification does not ensure a profit or protect against a loss.
Image: iStock.com/TolikoffPhotography
Try Fund Library Premium
For Free with a 30 day trial!